Quick answer
Define inactivity based on the type of email and the normal customer cycle, then send a limited, relevant re-engagement sequence to eligible contacts. If there is no meaningful response, suppress the contact from routine marketing sends.
Do not use one arbitrary inactivity period for every audience. A weekly newsletter, a seasonal service and a long consideration cycle have different natural rhythms. Choose rules that fit the relationship and document why.
What I would check first
Review consent source, signup date, last meaningful click or conversion, delivery history, complaint signals and whether the person has an active customer relationship. Open tracking alone is increasingly unreliable as a signal of interest.
Confirm that the list was collected with appropriate permission and that the sender identity, authentication and unsubscribe path are working. A re-engagement campaign should not be used to justify sending to contacts who should never have been on the list.
Decision framework
Use engagement and lifecycle context together. Suppress hard bounces and unsubscribed contacts promptly; exclude recent customers from irrelevant prospect messaging; and treat long-inactive contacts according to the value and risk of the relationship.
Make the re-engagement message honest and useful. Offer a clear choice to continue, update preferences or unsubscribe. Avoid fake urgency or making the recipient navigate a complicated process to stop receiving mail.
Implementation steps
Define eligibility, exclusions, sequence length, decision window and suppression rules. Test the segment before sending, verify links and preference handling, and make sure the automation cannot reactivate an unsubscribed or otherwise ineligible contact.
Review the outcome by segment and signup source. Keep the process documented so that a future campaign does not accidentally import suppressed contacts back into an active list.
Common mistakes and deliverability guidance
Do not repeatedly mail inactive contacts in the hope that volume will create engagement, remove people only because they did not open a privacy-affected email, or count an automated image load as a clear expression of interest.
Gmail's sender guidance includes authentication, spam-rate and unsubscribe requirements for relevant senders. List hygiene is not a substitute for authentication and compliance, but it supports a healthier sending programme.
Measurement and business implications
Track reactivation by meaningful clicks, replies or downstream actions, plus unsubscribe, complaint and bounce signals. Compare the value of reactivated contacts with the cost and risk of continued sending.
Use the deliverability, segmentation and welcome-sequence guides to make the policy part of a coherent lifecycle system rather than a one-off cleanup exercise.